If you’re comparing Dartmouth College’s Tuck School with Columbia University’s Graduate School of Business your application strategy is simply to get into the school with the biggest brandname. The reason: These programs are as different from each other as night and day. The differences cover everything from geography and facilities to culture and curriculum. This is big versus small, city versus rural life, a single crammed outdated facility versus a world-class MBA complex, a highly competitive versus a cooperative culture, and a broad, expansive curriculum that can be tailored to numerous industries or disciplines versus a general management approach.
Columbia is all about New York and the awesome resources it routinely leverages from the capital of the world. Unlike Tuck, it also enters two MBA classes a year, in January for students who don’t need or want a summer internship, and in September for a more conventional full-time MBA schedule.
The diversity of Columbia’s exceptional students is mind-boggling: In the Class of 2011, for example, are students who have interned at the White House, managed hedge funds, published books, produced TV shows and launched companies in the U.S. and abroad. The class includes an army ranger and recipient of the Bronze Star, the founder of the largest organic vegetable processing factory in northwestern China, a finalist on American Idol (we’re not kidding), and a three-time Grammy award-winning music producer.
Top Ten Reasons to Go to Dartmouth?
- It’s one of the five best MBA programs in the world.
- The MBA alumni network is arguably the best and most supportive of any business school.
- You want a premium MBA experience at a school that is completely focused on the full-time, two-year MBA and not a host of other programs that detract from it.
- You thrive in smaller, intimate settings.
- You prefer a highly collaborative and supportive student culture.
- You want to create important and enduring relationships with fellow students.
- You want to create important and lasting relationships with faculty.
- You want a general management perspective.
- You like small towns and tend to dislike big cities.
- You adore the outdoors.
Top Ten Reasons to Go to Columbia?
- It’s one of the six best MBA programs in the world.
- It’s all about location, location, location. That is, New York location.
- You want a deep and thorough education, not merely in finance but a subset of it, such as investment management, private equity, value investing or something even more obscure.
- You expect to work in New York and want to be part of an extremely strong alumni base in the city where every major company is populated with at least some key players who got their MBA ticket punched where you did.
- You are highly competitive and want to go through a tough, competitive MBA program.
- You thrive in a larger environment and enjoy being a smaller fish in a bigger pond.
- You want to be part of an extremely diverse class, with lots of international exposure.
- You don’t mind traffic, people congestion, overpriced housing, and putting up with the hassles of big city life.
- You love big city life, or at least badly want to try it out, and you tend to dislike small towns in isolated places.
- You root for the New York Yankees, love museums and Carnegie Hall.
The more detailed differences between Columbia and Dartmouth?
Geography: Columbia Business School is the quintessential big city university. Its location in New York, the business, financial and media center of the world, brings the school massive benefits: a living laboratory of markets and businesses, an endless supply of well-qualified adjunct teachers, and more visiting executives who gravitate to its classrooms to speak and lecture. The school estimates that it gets more than 500 guest speakers a year on campus. That is a networking opportunity that is unique. “We have a big advantage being in New York City because there are so many opportunities for students to visit local alumni in their work offices and for alums to come back and coach students on campus,” says Ethan Hanabury, a senior associate dean at Columbia. He estimates that as many as 3,000 alums come back to the school each year for conferences, classes, recruiting sessions, and mentoring programs. There are few cities in the world that are as alive, exciting and dynamic than New York. The drawback to Columbia’s location is also obvious: As one student put it, “It’s easier to get a little lost in New York, to feel a little less rooted if you’re from outside the area, and to be a little more anonymous.” The social dynamic is completely different as well. Because Columbia MBAs rarely live together but are spread throughout the city, they’re far more likely to be more competitive with each other. It’s easier to stab someone in the back when you rarely see them outside of class. Dartmouth’s Tuck is on the other extreme: Hanover is the quintessential New England college town. It’s quaint, picture perfect after a fresh snowfall, and fairly isolated. You fly here into a tiny airport in West Lebanon, six miles south of Hanover. When the weather turns bad, you face a white-knuckle flight onto the short landing strip that’s carved into a mountainside. Sleepy Hanover rolls up the sidewalks pretty early, with little variety in restaurants and bars. The Canoe Club, on Main St. in Hanover is pretty much it. Boston is a two-hour drive from the Tuck School.