The Trump Shock In The MBA Bubble

Donald Trump

Donald Trump

“Who here thinks Trump will win?,” asked Kevin Sharer, a senior lecturer at Harvard Business School. On Monday morning, the day before Trump’s upset victory in the Presidential election, only three out of nearly 90 MBA students in Sharer’s corporate strategy class raised their hands. After all, Donald Trump, the Wharton undergrad, was supported by only 3% of Harvard’s MBA students, according to a pre-election survey by The Harbus, the MBA student newspaper.

So when Trump pulled the proverbial rabbit out of a hat on Tuesday, there was utter shock on the campus where graduating MBAs this year year started jobs with compensation packages of $158,080 to start, more than three times the $51,939 median household income in America.

The mood on the HBS campus—and business school and university campuses all over the U.S.—is “somber and perplexed,” notes Preeya Sud, who will graduate from Harvard with her MBA next year. “No one expected this. HBS students are known to say, somewhat flippantly, that we live in a bubble…Just how much of a bubble we live in seems to finally be sinking in.”

Or, as one glum Harvard MBA student put it, “HBS gave the world Bush. Wharton gave us Trump.”

A PRIMAL SCREAM AT THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO, A MARCH AT HIS ALMA MATER

The upset victory by Trump has led to widespread protests and vigils on college campuses. At Trump’s Philadelphia alma mater, students marked his victory by marching in solidarity against him. Some professors cancelled classes and moved back exam dates and deadlines for papers. Wharton junior Jennifer Hutchens told The Daily Pennsylvanian, the student newspaper at Penn, that she spent election night crying with members of her sorority.  At the University of Chicago, hundreds of students gathered in the quad for a “primal scream” and an anti-Trump demonstration that included burning t-shirts and posters in support of the candidate.

The Harbus asked Harvard MBAs to anonymously share their reflections on Trump’s victory. Some 40 students immediately expressed their feelings the day after the election. Not surprisingly, most were shocked and stunned by the news. They called it “unconscionable,” “a vote for racism and misogyny,” “embarrassing, infuriating, terrifying,” and “what the ever lovin’ f?!?”

“I’m an Asian-American woman, a first-generation immigrant, and a first-time voter, having become a citizen in 2014,” wrote one Harvard MBA student. “During my citizenship ceremony, I felt so proud and excited to become an American. The origin country of every new citizen was announced that day to cheers and celebration. I felt I was entering the embrace of the greatest country in the world – one that honored my heritage and personal identity.

“Today, that excitement has fallen through a pit in my stomach. To me, Trump’s impending victory tells me everything I need to know about how I am seen by half of America. It tells me how little value is placed on me as a person of color, an immigrant, and a woman. I feel put in my place, and my place is not here.”

‘I FEEL WEIRDLY UNACCEPTED’

Added another HBS student, “As a brown woman who came to this country five years ago, I never once felt discriminated against and always appreciated how America is so progressive considering gay rights, equality, and pro-choice! And now I realize this was because I was primarily living in the blue states. Today, I’m appalled to see that the country I’ve loved actually has a majority that sees me as both brown and a woman. I feel weirdly unaccepted.”

The angst on college campuses all across the U.S. drew cynical responses from many Trump supporters. “I don’t see any option for the special snowflakes other than crying, screaming and stomping their feet until Trump resigns,” wrote a commenter to a story about protests by the Yale Daily News. “I’d like to help them cope by donating a couple of cases of binkies for the safe rooms — where should I ship them to?”

On the HBS campus, at least one MBA conceded he had supported the Republican candidate. “I’m one of the secret Trump supporters,” he wrote. “He’s an impossible candidate to be proud of supporting, or to even defend, but I truly believe he is the lesser of two evils and still very much an unknown in terms of how he will lead. My decision ultimately came down to my belief that our nation’s system of checks and balances will keep Trump in check, with even his own party guaranteed to challenge him, whereas Hillary will never be held accountable for her actions by any of the institutions that are supposed to do so – the courts, the media, even the FBI.”

‘OUR EDUCATION IS A GREAT PRIVILEGE BUT ALSO A BIG RESPONSIBILITY’

And at UPenn, College Republicans President and Wharton senior Jennifer Knesbach maintained her group’s neutrality. The club decided not to denounce Trump after recordings of him bragging about committing sexual assault were made public. “There has been a lot of mixed views within the club,” she told The Daily Pennsylvanian. “A lot of members were really unhappy today and a lot of our members were happy and excited about Trump’s win.”

At Yale University’s School of Management, Senior Associate Dean for Leadership Studies Jeffrey Sonnenfeld attributed Trump’s victory to the failure of elites to hear the concerns of disenfranchised blue collar workers. “Secretary Clinton has been a friend for 30 years and Trump – ultimately a friend for 12 years – after a rough start,” he says (see The B-School Professor & Donald Trump). ” Trump’s win is not primarily due to James Comey’s missteps, Vladimir Putin’s hostile intervention, Julianne Assange’s  malicious maneuvers, misguided trade isolationism,  or even the horrific and real lingering shadows of misogyny, nativism, bigotry.  Success and failure here is more attributable to images of trust and perceived hypocrisy as well as the candidates ability to pierce the elite bubble to  hear the concerns of much of the nation regarding trade, immigration, and jobs. “

One of the more thoughtful conclusions from an MBA student came from Harvard Business School’s Rafael Rivera, who was born in Mexico and who had worked for McKinsey & Company in the offices of Mexico City, Mumbai, and Dubai, and for the World Bank in Cambodia. “The fact that we are deeply surprised about the results reveals how disconnected we are from the average citizen,” wrote Rivera on a Huffington Post essay.

“While we have been blessed with an education at Harvard Business School, our situation might also put some distance between us and the vast majority of citizens. As aspiring leaders in business and politics, we cannot ignore the problems of our people. Inequality, stagnant wages, terrorism, and poor welfare are issues faced by developed and developing countries alike. Our education is a great privilege, but also a big responsibility to find real solutions to those problems.”

DON’T MISS: WHY TRUMP’S ELECTION IS GOOD FOR INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS SCHOOLS

  • MBAatTop10Program

    Corporate America has and always will uphold the democratic values of this country. They are the leaders and the progressers – the government lags. I worked for the federal government and decided to get a MBA for that reason. Not many of the brightest MBAs seek to go into politics. The private sector is where true democracy flourishes.

  • frankjaeger

    1 year have passed since I resigned from my last work and that decision changed everything for me… I started doing a job at home, for this company I found online, several hrs every day, and I profit now much more than i did on my office job… My payment for last month was for $9000… Amazing thing about this is that i have more time with my kids… CHILP.IT/8d93f4b

  • somsquared

    Interesting piece! Don’t forget my alma mater gave us Ruth Bader Ginsberg! So that is something that probably should have been highlighted in this piece too. Cornell has been pushing the boundries in academic and political area for centuries and Johnson is finally catching up to the top 10 ranking it should have always been.

  • Yaniv

    This is what I got to understand is that many voted for trump because they wanted to punish Clinton and the DNC for what they did to sanders. Childish attitude, you tricked my idol I will vote for your competitor.

  • PeaceLoveBusiness

    didn’t vote in the general for anyone on GOP besides Trump*

  • PeaceLoveBusiness

    I’m a Muslim Democrat and I voted for Trump. Economic growth is more important to me than highly biased media reports that didn’t seem that bad.

    Trump met with Obama and offered to keep parts of Obamacare and the media excoriated him for ‘changing position!’ …’he’s already flipping’….it seems nothing pleases this left-wing elite group. Honestly, any other GOP president would repeal Obamacare without as much as a second-though. Trump is considering keeping parts and amending if it makes sense. If not he will repeal. I’m hopeful and am in no way scared like I am being told I should be. This is America after all. P.S. I voted for Bernie and didn’t vote in the general.

  • WizK

    I heard she was a porn star! is that true? because it would be great for this profession to finally get respected.

  • Rimond

    “HBS gave us Bush, and Wharton gave us Trump” is this a call to reconsider business schools education? Does it mean that b schools are good only in producing managers but horrible in preparing leaders! From the naive admission standards of most top schools, I believe so, b schools produces mediocre managers. Not leaders, in fact, they produce terrible people. UNLIKE, law schools!

  • WhartonSucks

    His wife was an illegal immigrant – working here without the necessary visa. She however got the chance to become legal, later.

    But Trump would not give the same chance to other illegals because …

  • Stuart

    Utter palaver. The man’s a crook, has swindled countless people, and has a flighty temperament. Clinton earned a larger part of the vote — albeit as a flawed candidate. The news here is that you’ll be looking at these words sooner or later and realize how foolish you sound. Or just as likely you don’t reflect much on anything.

  • C. Taylor

    Clinton offered socialism and pretended it would be free. Trump offered growth and explained how this impacts regular workers.

    The only reason Clinton ever had a chance is the extreme bias in the media which fomented the current social unrest. Painting Trump as anything but socially liberal was trumped up by the media, but hey, now we have riots which we are supposed to accept as ‘protests’. Seriously, the guy’s wife did a risque spread in GQ in his 747–and she’s a legal immigrant.

    And btw, Trump was a long time donor to the Democrats.

  • J

    This piece is mostly quotes of MBA students complaining that the election did not go the way they thought it would. It really doesn’t even have anything to do with how a Trump presidency affects MBAs or MBA school. The article about Trump’s election showing an uptick for international B Schools makes sense for this website. This one just feels whiny in nature. Nothing substantive here.

  • BUT

    I think assessing your education, career, and subsequent impact of those on the communities around you without considering politics is operating in a vacuum. This is an opinion piece with anecdotes from top business school students. It is pertinent that we all consider how our time and talents can impact politics and fellow citizens regardless of affiliation.

  • J

    I think a political article like this doesn’t really belong on poetsandquants.