How The M7 Rank Against Each Other
You might expect the M7 schools to all rank naturally in the top seven positions of the most credible rankings. But you would be wrong. Because rankings are based on often flawed and misinformed methodologies, the media organizations that crank out these lists often have M7 schools outside the top seven.
In fact, several highly prominent lists have some of the M7 institutions far back in the pack, in 14th, 12th, and 9th place. Bloomberg Businessweek’s 2014 list, for example, ranks MIT Sloan 14th. The Economist has Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management in 12th place among U.S. MBA programs and 14th overall on its global list. U.S. News & World Report‘s 2014 survey put Columbia Business School 8th, the same position that Businessweek relegated the Harvard Business School in 2014.
Not to toot our own horn, but it’s worth noting that every M7 school is in the top seven positions of the 2014 composite ranking by Poets&Quants, further evidence that putting together all the most influential lists in a selectively weighted fashion is the best way to get the most authoritative ranking.
Of course, looking at the overall standing of a school in MBA rankings doesn’t give you the most complete picture of the strengths and weaknesses of an MBA program. Another way to look at these rankings is to parse them by category and that’s exactly what we’ve done in taking U.S. News’ specialty ranking and showing how each of the M7 schools fare. These rankings are determined by a survey of business school deans and MBA directors.
A word of caution should be issued on these latter rankings. Because they reflect the views of deans and MBA directors who often do not have direct experience with other schools, they are more likely to be based on “perception” rather than “reality.” Kellogg, for example, has made a major push into entrepreneurship, yet the school fails to receive a rank in this category by U.S. News. Wharton, long known as a school of finance, turns up pretty high in almost all the categories ranked by U.S. News, proving once again that Wharton has clearly outgrown its narrow definition as a school of finance.
The final table on the page parses some of the more telling data from the different rankings, from Forbes‘ highly conservative estimate of the payback period for the degree (it fails to conclude scholarship grants) and U.S. News‘ surveys of corporate recruiters and academics to The Financial Times‘ alumni recommendation and academic research rankings.
2014 Rankings For the M7 MBA Programs
Source: P&Q analysis
The Best M7 MBA Programs By Discipline or Specialty
|Production & Operations||5||NR||3||NR||8||6||1|
|Supply Chain Logistics||4||15||7||NR||18||12||1|
Source: U.S. News & World Report 2014 specialty rankings
Parsing The Rankings On The Best M7 MBA Programs
|U.S. News Recruiter Scores||4.6||4.6||4.6||4.4||4.3||4.4||4.5|
|U.S. News Peer Scores||4.8||4.8||4.8||4.8||4.4||4.7||4.7|
|Forbes’ Payback Period||4.1 yrs||4.0 yrs||4.0 yrs||3.7 yrs||3.9 yrs||3.8 yrs||4.0 yrs|
|FT’s Alum Recommendation Rank||2||1||3||4||8||6||5|
|FT’s Research Rank||10||1||2||7||7||13||4|
|FT’s Salary Increase||100%||113%||99%||100%||116%||94%||101%|
Source: Various rankings