Consulting Overtakes Finance At Booth

Chicago Booth MBA students

For the first time ever, more graduating MBAs from the University of Chicago’s Booth School of Business accepted jobs in the booming consulting industry than in finance. For a school where finance has always dominated, consulting’s rise is yet another indication of the decline of finance in MBA recruiting.

Ever since the Great Recession of 2007-2008, the leading schools that funnel MBAs into Wall Street—Wharton, Columbia, Booth and NYU Stern—have seen fewer and fewer of their graduates headed into the core finance jobs in investment banking, investment managment, private equity, venture capital and hedge funds. But never before has an elite school known for its strength in finance seen another industry topple the financial sector as the leading employer of its MBAs.

Some 34.7% of Booth’s Class of 2017 ventured into consulting, up more than seven full percentage points from the 27.5% a year earlier. MBAs going into the financial sector, meantime, fell to 30.7% of the class, down from 36.0% last year. As recently as 2010, 45.0% of graduating Boothies rushed into the finance industry. The biggest declines in financial services occurred at what the school calls “diversified finance,” a category that drew only 3.8% of this year’s class, down from 7.7% last year. Investment management, private equity and insurance also fell. I-banking jobs showed a slight rise to 14.7%, from 13.6%.

HIGHEST MEDIAN SALARIES OF $147,000 GO TO MBAS WHO ENTERED THE CONSULTING INDUSTRY

In an interim report on the employment prospects of the Class of 2017, Chicago Booth also reported that median starting salaries and sign-on bonuses remained unchanged this year at $125,000 and $25,000, respectively. But a slightly higher percentage of graduates received sign-on bonuses in the interim report, 66%, versus the 60% of graduates who got signing bonuses last year.

As a result, total median compensation, adjusted for the percentage of students receiving sign-on bonuses, was up slightly to $141,503, from $140,020. For the first time, Chicago Booth did not disclose other guaranteed compensation for its graduates. Last year, Booth said that 16% of its graduates received median extra comp of $25,000, pay that is typically reported by MBAs who head into finance.

“We had a really strong year at Booth, says Julie Morton, associate dean of career services and corporate relations. The students did really well. There wasn’t a lot of job search angst in the spring of last year, and the people who are still looking are fine with the fact they were still in the market.”

Booth said that 91% of its graduating class had job offers at graduation and 97% gained offers three month after commencement. The final 3%, adds Morton, were “people who were looking for very specific stuff that was just going to take longer to get. They were willing to hold out and we stop officially tracking three months post.”

FOUR OF THE FIVE TOP EMPLOYERS THIS YEAR WERE CONSULTING FIRMS

Four of the top five employers this year were all consultants: McKinsey & Co. led the pack with 48 hires, followed by Amazon and Boston Consulting Group, both employing 26 Booth MBAs, then Bain & Co., with 22, and Accenture, with 13. The first financial services firm—Morgan Stanley—on the list came in sixth place, with 11 hires.

“It’s the first time in recent history that consulting has outpaced financial services, for sure, if you lump everything finance related together,” adds Morton. “What the industry figures mask is that if you look at it by function, consulting and finance are just about the same.” The interim report shows consulting at 38.3% by function, versus 37.0% for finance.

Morton attributes the shift from finance to both changing student preferences and less hiring by financial service firms. “The financial services appetite for MBA talent has certainly diminished from what it was in its heyday,” she says. “But student interests at Booth have certanly gotten way more diverse. They are interested in a broader range of employment opportunities. Students are getting have become more interested in lifestyle issues and the changes banks have made on that front have helped somewhat but students are interested in going into careers where they have some control over how they spend their time.”

Median starting salaries for those taking consulting jobs were the highest of any industry employer this year at $147,000, up from $145,000 a year earlier and $140,000 two years ago. In contrast, median salaries to MBAs who took jobs in the financial sector was $125,000, some $22,000 less than consulting. Boothies who went into finance, however, received higher sign-on bonuses that helped to diminish the gap. Median signing bonuses in finance were $40,000 versus $25,000 in consulting.

  • avivalasvegas

    You don’t really know where I went to B school M7 – I could have been sitting next to you in the Jake for two years for all you know 😉

  • M7hopeful

    You’re either hopelessly disconnected from reality or purposely making things up. I’m still not sure which.

    There is very little b-school “rivalry” between Booth and Kellogg. The two schools attract different types of people, sit in different parts of the city, and generally speaking don’t interact much. Outside of the occasional sporting event or Battle of the Bands, there’s nothing there worth being rivals over. Hell, most people at Kellogg haven’t even met people from Booth before they graduate.

    I have no clue where you’re pulling your numbers from. I just pulled actual data from employment reports from Kellogg for the percentage of grads going into the consulting industry:

    2009: 38% going into consulting
    2010: 31% going into consulting
    2011: 37% going into consulting
    2012: 35% going into consulting
    2013: 36% going into consulting
    2014: 35% going into consulting
    2015: 35% going into consulting
    2016: 33% going into consulting

    I can’t find data going back that early for incoming class profiles, but the last four years are as follows:

    Class of 2016: 25% coming from consulting
    Class of 2017: 25% coming from consulting
    Class of 2018: 19% coming from consulting
    Class of 2019: 27% coming from consulting

    I don’t see any “decline” in the data.

    You act like you know what “students who actually pay to participate in the school’s small group study dynamic” want, but here’s the thing: *you didn’t go there*. And more to the point, I *did* go there. I think it’s clear whose opinion should carry more weight.

  • avivalasvegas

    Ah M7Hopeful, the P&Q resident, perpetually naive, Kellogg fanboy. Booth has so much to do with Kellogg. It’s the b-school rivalry to end all rivalries.

    As far as consulting admission rates go, a quick look at the last 5 years will show a decline from a high of the low 30’s% to the current mid 20’s% level. that’s a decline from 1 in 3 students to 1 in 4 consultants. May not seem like “much” to the likes of you but for .ppt fluff averse students, like I was, it’s night and day.

  • M7hopeful

    Leave it to aviva to leave a comment about Kellogg on an article that has nothing to do with Kellogg.

    For the record, the consulting admission/generation rate at Kellogg really hasn’t changed much over the last 5-10 years, so your otherwise-robust analysis doesn’t hold much water.

  • so long, IB/finance! looks like consulting is here to stay

  • I wonder if this’ll change once interest rates go up

  • 2014 Grad

    Forecasting based on a sample size of one (what happened to Kellogg some time ago). Punditry is alive and well on this forum!

  • reckmondatary

    go to HBS MBA website, career report. You will find them there!

  • Hahaha

    ah, where do you get this information?

  • Hahaha

    This goes to show that more Boothies could go to consulting if they wanted to.

    This will mean a rankings bump in those stupid rankings that use salary/ROI as the main criteria like Forbes and FT.

  • reckmondatary

    And for the first time, median base for HBS going to consulting is $150K. It used to be similar to Wharton/Stanford, Now it is above them.

  • Yes. That is why the overall category for both finance and technology is in CAPS with the sub-categories in lower case.

  • avivalasvegas

    Truly a sad day for Boothies…

  • MBA alum

    You may want to note that the Industry Choices chart on page two is a bit confusing since it technically double counts some categories. It shows the overall Finance figures plus the figures for the six finance sub-categories (IB, PE, VC, Investment Mgt, Diversified Finance, and Insurance).