USC Steals Wharton Dean To Head Marshall School Without A Full Search

Wharton Dean Geoffrey Garrett

Wharton Dean Geoffrey Garrett

In a highly unusual move, the dean of the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School has agreed to accept the deanship at the University of Southern California’s Marshall School of Business.

Geoffrey Garrett, who has been dean of Wharton for just under five years, will stay at Wharton for one more year before assuming the job in July of 2020. His appointment is likely to fuel even more controversy at the school because it occurred without a thorough search for a new leader of the Marshall School. Gareth James, a Marshall professor for more than two decades, will serve as interim dean beginning July 1 and lasting until Garrett’s arrival the following year.

Garrett will succeed the highly popular Jim Ellis, who departs the job at the end of this month, forced out by interim USC President Wanda Austin and Provost Michael Quick for undisclosed reasons. The Los Angeles Times, citing unnamed sources, attributed the decision to cut short Ellis’ third consecutive five-year term as dean to mishandled gender and racial bias complaints at the school, a claim that Ellis has vigorously denied.

GARRETT WAS HIRED WITHOUT A FULL SEARCH

The decision to oust the dean has led to widespread controversy, campus protests and bad publicity at a university already embroiled in a series of negative news, from its prominence in the most recent college admissions scandal to earlier reports that a long-time gynecologist at the campus health center had mistreated students for decades. And now the administration’s choice in bringing on Garrett will give Ellis’ supporters more ammunition to attack the university.

Garrett, sources say, is being hired without a full search for a successor, and Garrett was the only person interviewed by the search committee and a handful of deans from other USC schools. In a brief interview with the Los Angeles Times, Garrett said he had learned about the Marshall school as part of a re-accreditation team this spring and the trip “piqued my interest and curiosity.” The Times described him as being “more circumspect” when asked about the search and interview process for the job.

“This was not a search,” maintains a source close to the school who spoke on condition of anonymity. “This was a coronation. They hired him in a vacuum. This is all about declaring a victory lap by Austin and Quick as they are going out the door. Does that mean that he is the best fit for the Marshall School? Absolutely not. You can’t know that because he didn’t have to compete with other candidates for the job.”

A spokesperson for USC disagrees that a thorough search wasn’t done. He says the university engaged the search firm of SpencerStuart and the university held “listening sessions for the Marshall community” and “provided a way for the community to contact the search firm and provost directly.” Asked if the search committee interviewed more than a single candidate for the job, the spokesman said only “the details of the search are confidential.”

PRAISED FOR EXPANDING WHARTON’S GLOBAL PRESENCE IN DATA ANALYTICS, ENTREPRENEURSHIP & BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS’

USC Marshall Dean James G. Ellis

USC Marshall Dean James G. Ellis

Meantime, Austin and Quick are also surrendering their positions at USC as interim president and provost on exactly the same day that Ellis packs up his office and leaves for the last time on June 30th. Austin is being succeeded by Carol L. Folt, the recently departed chancellor of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

Little more than two weeks before he leaves as provost, Quick made the announcement in a memo to faculty, staff, and students at Marshall this morning. Quick described Garrett as “a strong leader who has been guiding Wharton since 2014 as it has expanded its global presence in data analytics, entrepreneurship, behavioral economics and other areas, and he is a highly-cited academic.”

In his memo, Quick thanked the Marshall Faculty Advisory Search Committee for its work during the search process and “for providing Dr. Garrett with a comprehensive understanding of the Marshall School during his interview.”

Ellis’ advocates were clearly disappointed in the outcome. “I can well appreciate why Geoff Garrett would want a one-year cooling-off period before coming to Marshall,” says Lloyd Greif, a Marshall alum and donor and a strong supporter of Ellis (see The MBA Alum Leading The Fight To Save A Business School Dean). “Temperatures are running pretty hot at the school right now. I’m sorry, but the end doesn’t justify the means. Whether Geoff Garrett’s the best person for the job is not the point. Jim Ellis did nothing wrong and should still be dean for the next three years. He doesn’t deserve the disrespect and mistreatment accorded him by the university.”

FOURTH B-SCHOOL DEANSHIP IN LESS THAN NINE YEARS

In an announcement put out at 8:35 a.m. PST, University of Pennsylvania President Amy Gutmann and Provost Wendell Pritchett notified the Wharton community of the surprise news. They said that Garrett had done an “absolutely superb job in leading Wharton for the past five years…In preparation for Geoff’s departure from Penn, we will very shortly initiate the process of forming an Ad Hoc Consultative Committee of faculty, students, and alumni to advise us on the selection of the next Dean of the Wharton School. Penn Medicine EVP/Dean J. Larry Jameson has agreed to chair the committee and our expectation is that we will announce a new Dean prior to Geoff’s departure. Since Geoff will remain at Wharton through the end of the coming academic year, we will have ample time to celebrate his extraordinary leadership. In the meantime, we hope you will join me in extending warm wishes to Geoff on this new adventure in his life as well as thanks for his many contributions to Wharton’s success.”

In going to USC’s Marshall School, Garrett will be taking on his fourth deanship of a business school in what would be less than nine years (see Wharton’s New Job-Hopping Dean). Before Wharton, he had been dean for a year and one-half at the University of New South Wales’ Australian School of Business and for a single year at the University of Sydney’s business school. Garrett will be leaving his Wharton deanship one year short of his seven-year term.

At USC, he will assume the reins of a business school that is ranked well below Wharton with far fewer resources (see Wharton’s Geoff Garrett: USC Not A Step Down). Wharton’s full-time MBA enrollment is nearly four times the size of the Marshall School, roughly 1,700 students versus 450, though the Marshall School boasts a substantially larger undergraduate population, slightly more than 4,000 students to Wharton’s 2,500. Currently, Poets&Quants ranks Wharton’s full-time MBA in a tie with Harvard Business School. USC’s Marshall School, though on an upward trajectory under departing Dean James Ellis, places 22nd in the U.S. and its full-time MBA program fails to make the Top 25 in either Forbes or The Financial Times rankings.

The Australian-born Garrett, however, has had strong ties to California. His wife is from Northern California and Garrett thinks of himself as an “honorary Californian.” He lived in the Los Angeles area for eight years. From 2001 to 2005, he was a political science professor at UCLA and dean of the university’s International Institute. He then moved over to USC as a professor of international relations and president of the Pacific Council on International Policy until 2009. Garrett also taught in the political science department at Stanford University from 1988 to 1997. Even though he has been gone from the area for quite some time, he still owns a home in West L.A.