Kellogg | Mr. Concrete Angel
GRE 318, GPA 3.33
Harvard | Mr. Finance
GMAT 750, GPA 3.0
Harvard | Mr. Military Quant
GMAT 730, GPA 3.6
Harvard | Ms. Quadrilingual Amazon
GMAT 710, GPA 3.9
Harvard | Mr. Healthcare PE
GRE 340, GPA 3.5
INSEAD | Mr. Product Manager
GMAT 740, GPA 63%
Harvard | Ms. Female Sales Leader
GMAT 740 (target), GPA 3.45
Harvard | Mr. Renewables Athlete
GMAT 710 (1st take), GPA 3.63
Kellogg | Ms. Big4 M&A
GMAT 740, GPA 3.7
Harvard | Mr. Defense Engineer
GMAT 730, GPA 3.6
Wharton | Mr. Future Non-Profit
GMAT 720, GPA 8/10
Duke Fuqua | Mr. Army Aviator
GRE 314, GPA 3.8
Harvard | Ms. Gay Techie
GRE 332, GPA 3.88
INSEAD | Mr. INSEAD Aspirant
GRE 322, GPA 3.5
Chicago Booth | Ms. Indian Banker
GMAT 740, GPA 9.18/10
MIT Sloan | Ms. Rocket Engineer
GMAT 710, GPA 3.9
Stanford GSB | Mr. Army Engineer
GRE 326, GPA 3.89
Duke Fuqua | Mr. Salesman
GMAT 700, GPA 3.0
Tuck | Mr. Liberal Arts Military
GMAT 680, GPA 2.9
Columbia | Mr. Energy Italian
GMAT 700, GPA 3.5
Duke Fuqua | Mr. Quality Assurance
GMAT 770, GPA 3.6
Harvard | Mr. African Energy
GMAT 750, GPA 3.4
NYU Stern | Ms. Luxury Retail
GMAT 730, GPA 2.5
Stanford GSB | Ms. Russland Native
GMAT 700, GPA 3.5
Harvard | Mr. Aerospace Engineer
GRE 327, GPA 3.92
N U Singapore | Mr. Naval Officer
GMAT 710, GPA 3.2
UCLA Anderson | Mr. Microsoft India
GMAT 780, GPA 7.14

Swimming In An Elite Academic Pond

Ivy League


It’s easy to despair about the state of higher education. William Deresiewicz, the author of Excellent Sheep: The Miseducation of the American Elite and the Way to a Meaningful Life, has spent a good chunk of his adult life in the Ivy League, both as a student and as a teacher, and he has a few bones to pick — with his “careerist” and “sheep”-like students, those “out-of-touch, entitled little shit[s],” a “race of bionic hamsters” who “color in the lines,” but also their helicopter parents, the elite college admissions process (“squatting like a dragon at the entrance of adulthood”), over-specialized professors, Goldman Sachs, lawyers, economics majors, ineffective career services offices, Teach for America, the Ivy League (with special digs against the “notoriously anti-intellectual” Princeton and Dartmouth), the U.S. News rankings, admissions consultants (“ghost-writers”), degree-collecting James Franco, Tiger Mom Amy Chua, and even the well-meaning soul who wants to improve access to drinking water through clean technology… because he must just be checking some box to get ahead.  Whew.

Anna Ivey, a prominent admissions consultant, reviews the new controversial book on elite education

Anna Ivey, a prominent admissions consultant, reviews the new controversial book on elite education

That Deresiewicz wants to burn the whole house down doesn’t make him wrong about some of the underlying problems. He is only the latest in a long line of critics of elite American education, and like many before him, he yearns for a golden age of education that I’m not convinced has ever existed among name-brand schools: a world where people seek only a life of the mind and self-exploration, where they are motivated primarily by a sense of justice and revolution, and where they pursue their education without any concern for grades or employment or the conventional (if sometimes hollow) markers of success.


Like any manifesto worth its salt, his proposals to fix the system are well meaning and mostly quixotic. His advice to young people is to find the moral courage to opt out of the competition to attend an elite college, to break up with their BFF parents, and maybe even to transfer to state school. Indeed, there are numerous references to morality in this book, as if it were immoral to want to attend Harvard or Yale. Of course plenty of students already opt out of the race to the Ivies. The fact that many of them wouldn’t get into Harvard or Yale is not an indictment of those students, but it shouldn’t be an indictment of the Ivies, either.

He is right that the Ivies don’t always snap up the “passionate weirdos,” the brilliant autodidacts who “approach the work of the mind with a pilgrim spirit.” And if those students do end up at the Ivies (which is really just a shorthand for the big and famous American research universities that everyone has heard of), it’s true that the real visionaries and outliers like Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, and Elizabeth Holmes don’t always stick around to graduate. Of course some of the passionate weirdos happily graduate from those brand-name schools and go off and do interesting things. I’ve encountered enough of them to know that they are not unicorns.

About The Author

John A. Byrne is the founder and editor-in-chief of C-Change Media, publishers of Poets&Quants and four other higher education websites. He has authored or co-authored more than ten books, including two New York Times bestsellers. John is the former executive editor of Businessweek, editor-in-chief of Businessweek. com, editor-in-chief of Fast Company, and the creator of the first regularly published rankings of business schools. As the co-founder of CentreCourt MBA Festivals, he hopes to meet you at the next MBA event in-person or online.