Toggle navigation
MBA Watch Logo
MBA Watch Sponsor
Rice Business | Mr. Doesn’t Know When To Quit
GRE 331, GPA 3
Stanford GSB | Mr. Anti W2
GRE 331, GPA 3.0
MIT Sloan | Ms. Sassy
GRE 329, GPA 3.46
MBA Watch Sponsor
Kellogg SOM | Mr. HealthAI
GMAT 700, GPA 3
Harvard | Mr. Global Consultant Leader
GMAT GMAT FE 705, GPA 7
INSEAD | Mr. SE To PM
GMAT 675, GPA 3.0
MBA Watch Sponsor
Harvard | Mr. Data Econ
GMAT 750, GPA 4
Harvard | Mr. Energetic Indian
GMAT 760, GPA 9
Stanford GSB | Ms. Multifaceted Desi
GRE 309, GPA 4
MBA Watch Sponsor
Tepper | Ms. MRI Gal
GRE N/A, GPA 3.3
Columbia | Ms. Big4 CPA To MBA
GMAT 730, GPA 3.69
Cornell Johnson | Ms. Indonesian Tech
GMAT 740, GPA 3.02
MBA Watch Sponsor
Stanford GSB | Mr. IB To TFA
GMAT 750, GPA 3.4
NYU Stern | Ms. CA – Controller
GRE 321, GPA 8
Chicago Booth | Ms. Low GPA High Impact Care
GMAT 685, GPA 2.56
MBA Watch Sponsor
PQ Logo
Featured Schools
University of Cambridge Judge Business School logo
NYU Color (440 x 200 px)
Rice Logo
IESE Business School logo 440 x 200
University of Pittsburgh Katz
MBA Full time event
Today's Featured Schools
Featured Schools
University of Cambridge Judge Business School logo
NYU Color (440 x 200 px)
Rice Logo
IESE Business School logo 440 x 200
University of Pittsburgh Katz
MBA Full time event
  • Home
  • Main Menu
  • Most Recent
  • This Week’s Most Viewed
  • GMAT Master
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
  • Events
  • Study In UK
  • Special Reports
Rankings
  • MBA
  • Online MBA
  • Specialized Masters
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Executive MBA
  • Undergraduate Business Schools
News & Features
  • All Business School News
  • MBA
  • International MBA News
  • Online MBA
  • Specialized Masters
  • Admissions
Inside Business Education
  • THE Register
  • Thought Leadership
MBA
  • School Profiles
  • Rankings
  • News
  • Jobs
  • Faculty & Leadership
  • Best 40 Under 40 Professors
  • Events
Students
  • News & Features
  • Meet The Class
  • Best & Brightest MBAs
  • Best & Brightest Online MBAs
  • Women In Business School
Careers & Pay
  • News, Advice, & Trends
Online MBA
  • News & Advice
  • School Profiles
  • Rankings
  • Events
  • Pursuing Purpose At Gies
Masters Degrees in Business
  • News & Advice
  • Specialized Masters Directory
  • Rankings
  • Business Analytics
  • Master's In Management
  • Events
Financing
  • Financing Your Degree
Study IN Series
  • Study In France
  • Study In UK
Admissions
  • News & Advice
  • Admissions Consultant Directory
  • Your MBA Game Plan
  • Admissions Gateway
  • Getting Into HBS, GSB, & Wharton
  • Handicapping Your MBA Odds
  • MBA Watch
  • Events
GMAT & GRE
  • News & Advice
  • GMAT Master
More Resources
  • FREE: Insider Guides
  • FREE: Successful Essays To The GSB & HBS
  • Special Reports
Events
Videos
Podcasts
Executive MBA
Undergrad
Full Archive

About | Privacy Policy | Advertising| Editorial | Contact Us

Follow Us

Subscribe | Login

  1. Home
  2. Sponsored Blogs: Insights & Advice From MBA Admissions Consultants
  3. Why the MBA Admissions Committee Said No

Why the MBA Admissions Committee Said No

by: Karen Marks, President and Founder of North Star Admissions Consulting on August 15, 2017 | 1,336 Views
August 15, 2017
    • Copy Link
    • Share on Facebook
    • Share on Twitter
    • Email
    • Share on LinkedIn
    • Share on WhatsApp
    • Share on Reddit

When I was the Associate Director of Admissions for Tuck, I was often really excited about candidates who I would meet on the road or at events. We would have great conversations, and I would start to envision them as part of the Tuck community. Unfortunately, when I finally reviewed their applications there were often avoidable but fatal mistakes that precluded the MBA admissions committee from admitting them. Learn from their failure, and help the committee say yes.

Garbled Goals.

The bottom line is that business schools will not admit people who can’t get the jobs they want when they graduate. If your goals don’t make sense given your work history, are too vague (“I want an MBA to shift gears”) or don’t require business school the MBA admissions committee simply won’t admit you. For tips about how to articulate your goals, please read these blogs.

Elephants in the Room.

I have admitted people and worked with successful clients who have all sorts of “imperfections” that you might think are deal breakers, like super weak grades or test scores and job gaps. You really, truly can get into top 5 schools with these blemishes, AS LONG AS YOU EXPLAIN THEM. (And as long as the rest of your application is as strong as possible.) The key is to mitigate what you can, and to incentivize the MBA admissions committee to admit you despite the flags. It’s crucial to demonstrate humility, maturity and self-awareness.

Tepid School Love.

All MBA programs look for people who are really going to contribute to the school culture, and who truly want to be there. Yield is also an issue, even for the top programs. Do yourself a favor and get really specific and enthusiastic about the school. Talk about courses, clubs, and social opportunities in detail, with the right names. Network as much as possible, and take any opportunity to interview on campus.

Shaping a business school class is a privilege, and tremendously fun. When you interact with members of the MBA admissions committee, remember that they are genuinely excited to meet you – and really hoping that your application matches the terrific impression that you are making in person.


Karen has more than 12 years of experience evaluating candidates for admission to Dartmouth College and to the Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth. Since founding North Star Admissions Consulting in 2012, she has helped applicants gain admission to the nation’s top schools, including Stanford, Harvard, Yale, Wharton, MIT, Tuck, Columbia, Kellogg, Booth, Haas, Duke, Johnson, Ross, NYU, UNC, UCLA, Georgetown and more. Clients have been awarded more than $47 million dollars in scholarships, and more than 98% have gotten into one of their top choice schools.

Trending

How To Write Stellar Booth MBA Essays

Dr. Judith Silverman Hodara Fortuna

The ‘Introduce Yourself’ MBA Essay

highlight-growth-in-mba-application

How To Highlight Growth In Your MBA Application

How To Secure Deferred Enrollment At Top MBA Programs

Matt Symonds, Co-Founder and Director at Fortuna Admissions

Applying In Round 3: What Are Your Chances?

What It’s Really Like To Build A Startup At Wharton

MBA Career Vision Part 2: Long-Term Vision Vs. Short-Term Goal

Personal MBA Coach’s Tips For “Choice” Essays

Tagged: getting rejected by a school, how an MBA admissions committee decides, Karen Marks, MBA admissions committee, North Star Admissions Consulting, Why you didn't get in to business school

Post navigation

Previous Article: Job Satisfaction Rates At Top I-Banks
Next Article: 29 Essays That Got Applicants Into HBS
  • Stay Informed. Sign Up! Login
    Logout
    Search for:
  • Personal MBA Coach's Chicago Booth Essay Tips
  • Partner Blogs

    A CBS Insider’s Guide To Acing The Columbia MBA Essays

    by Cassandra Pittman, Fortuna Admissions (2 days ago)

    What Europe’s MBA Admissions Directors Want You To Know

    by Matt Symonds, Fortuna Admissions (2 weeks ago)
    MBA specialization with Melissa Jones from Fortuna

    6 MBA Specializations To Supercharge Your Career

    by Melissa Jones, Fortuna Admissions (2 weeks ago)
    NEW Karen Marks Photo

    Advice Column: Predictions For The 2025/2026 MBA Application Cycle

    by Karen Marks, North Star Admissions Consulting (2 weeks ago)

    How To Stand Out In The Application Pile

    by Matt Symonds, Fortuna Admissions (1 month ago)
  • Online MBA Hub Specialized Masters Directory Business Analytics Hub MBA Admissions Consultants Assess My MBA Odds

Our Partner Sites: Poets&Quants for Execs | Poets&Quants for Undergrads | Tipping the Scales | We See Genius

About Poets&Quants | P&Q News Archives | Privacy Policy | Advertising & Partnerships | Editorial | Contact Us | Sign In / Register

Copyright© 2025 C Change Media, LLC All Rights Reserved.

Website Design By: Yellowfarmstudios.com