Preparing For Alumni-Led MBA Interviews

An interview with a business school alum is a different experience from an interview with a member of the admissions committee, and it calls for different preparation. Your interviewer has usually seen very little of your application. They may follow the school’s suggested questions closely or barely at all. And afterward, they write a report that the admissions committee reads alongside everything else in your file.

Schools that use alumni interviewers are placing real trust in their graduates’ judgment. Alumni don’t make the final decision, but their report gives the committee something no essay can: a sense of how you come across in person, how you think on your feet, and whether a graduate of the program would want you as a classmate. Stanford Graduate School of Business (GSB), INSEAD, Columbia Business School and Northwestern’s Kellogg School of Management are among the top schools that draw on alumni to interview candidates, while others rely on admissions officers or current students.

At Fortuna Admissions, our coaches have sat on both sides of this conversation, as admissions directors reading interview reports and as alumni interviewers writing them. Below, I share our insights into what alumni are listening for and how to prepare. If you’d like to talk through your own interview strategy, you can sign up for a free consultation with a Fortuna coach.

WHAT MAKES AN ALUMNI INTERVIEW DIFFERENT?

The biggest difference is how much your interviewer knows about you going in. At most schools that use alumni, the interviewer receives your resume and little else, so they arrive without having read your essays. That gives you a fresh start, and it also means you can’t assume they already know your story. Your background, your goals and your reasons for choosing the school all need to come across clearly in the conversation itself.

The second difference is tone. Alumni interviews tend to be more conversational than those led by admissions staff, and a warm interviewer can make the hour feel like coffee with a friendly colleague. Enjoy that, while keeping your professional bearing. The alum is still evaluating everything you say, and a relaxed atmosphere can lead to fluffy answers. On the other hand, some alumni are more buttoned-up by nature, and you may find yourself in a fairly formal interview.

Finally, alumni vary in how closely they stick to the brief. Schools train and guide their interviewers, often with suggested questions, but some alumni follow the list to the letter while others let their own curiosity steer the conversation. Stanford GSB, for example, describes its interview as a structured behavioral conversation about what you have done in recent years, conducted by a trained alum or a member of the admissions team.

	In a typical alumni-led interview
What your interviewer has seen	Usually your resume only
Who decides	The admissions committee, with the interviewer’s report as one input of many in a holistic review
Tone	Conversational, though it depends on the interviewer’s personal style
Setting	In person (an office or a coffee shop) or virtual, depending on the school and your location
Length	Often around 45 minutes, though anything from 30 to 90 minutes is possible
Questions asked	Determined by the school’s guidance, plus whatever the interviewer is curious about

 

How much does the interviewer’s report matter? It is one input among many, and a strong interview is no guarantee of admission. It can, however, meaningfully strengthen your case, and a weak report is hard for the rest of an application to overcome.

Says Fortuna’s Caroline Diarte Edwards (former Director of Admissions at INSEAD), “At INSEAD, candidates interview with two alumni, and the committee reads both reports alongside the file. When two separate interviewers describe the same person, with the same strengths and the same clear sense of direction, that consistency is very persuasive. When the reports pull in different directions, it leads to uncertainty that rarely plays in the candidate’s favor.”

HOW SHOULD YOU PREPARE FOR AN ALUMNI-LED INTERVIEW?

Because no two alumni interviews are alike, the aim of preparation is to know your material so well that you can adapt to whichever conversation you find yourself in. In our experience, five areas make the biggest difference.

1. KNOW YOUR STORY INSIDE OUT

Your interviewer may only have your resume, so you need to be able to walk them through your path in a way that flows: the transitions you made, why you made them, and what you learned along the way. The logic connecting your past experience, your short-term goal and your longer-term vision should be easy to follow for someone hearing it for the first time. Practice a version of your story that takes 60 to 90 seconds, since “Walk me through your resume” is a very common opening.

Alumni interviews also lean heavily on behavioral questions. Prepare four or five versatile stories from your recent experience that show leadership (with or without formal authority), teamwork under pressure, how you handled a setback, conflict or ambiguity, and the impact you had. The STAR framework (Situation, Task, Action, Result) is a useful structure. Spend most of your time on the action, since that is where the interviewer learns how you operate. A well-chosen story can answer several different questions, which is what makes it versatile.

Fortuna’s Rachel Erickson Hee (Stanford GSB alum and former admissions interviewer) comments, “As a GSB alumni interviewer, I had the candidate’s resume and a set of behavioral questions, and my job was to bring that person to life for the admissions committee in a written report. The candidates I could write about most convincingly gave me specifics: what they did, what they said, how others responded, and what they would do differently next time. When an answer stayed general or slipped into ‘we,’ I kept asking follow-up questions, and that used up time they could have spent on their best stories.”

As a GSB alumni interviewer, I had the candidate’s resume and a set of behavioral questions, and my job was to bring that person to life for the admissions committee in a written report. The candidates I could write about most convincingly gave me specifics showing how they made a difference: what they did, why they did it, what they said, how others responded, and what happened as a result. When an answer stayed vague or slipped into ‘we,’ it made their stories less compelling and effective at helping me capture why they were special in my report.”

2. RESARCH THE SCHOOL, AND THE PERSON ACROSS THE TABLE

Alumni want to see that you’ve done your homework on their school. Be ready to reference specific courses, centers or clubs that connect to your goals, and to speak about the parts of the culture and community that genuinely resonate with you, whether that is Kellogg’s collaborative ethos, Columbia’s New York advantage or Stanford’s emphasis on values and personal growth. The strongest answers to “Why this school?” draw on conversations you’ve had with students and alumni, and they are specific enough to convince someone who lived the experience.

If you’re given your interviewer’s name, look them up on LinkedIn beforehand. Knowing their industry, career path and any shared interests helps you find natural points of connection and ask better questions about their MBA experience. Use what you learn lightly, though. You want to come across as well prepared, not as an internet stalker.

My colleague Caroline Diarte Edwards, who oversaw a pool of over 3000 alumni interviewers at INSEAD, adds, “Alumni bring their own culture and professional style into the room. An INSEAD interview with an alum in Singapore can feel quite different from one in Paris, New York or São Paulo. Read the person in front of you and adapt your register to them, while keeping the substance of your story consistent.”

3. TREAT IT AS A CONVERSATION, WITH STRUCTURE

An alumni interview is designed to feel like a conversation, and the candidates who do best listen carefully and answer the question that was actually asked. Keep your responses structured and concise so the interviewer has room to follow up, and show curiosity by reflecting on what the alum shares. Rambling is the most common mistake we see in friendly, conversational interviews.

Your questions at the end deserve thoughtful preparation. Your interviewer is giving up their time because they care about their school, and thoughtful questions show respect while helping you judge whether the program is right for you. Skip anything you could answer with a quick internet search. Questions like these tend to open up a good discussion:

• “What surprised you most about your MBA experience?”
•  “Which courses or professors had the biggest impact on your career?”
•  “How has the alumni network supported you since graduation?”

Rachel Erickson Hee adds, “Most alumni interviewers volunteer because they loved their time at the school and want to find people who will further enrich the student and alumni community. The questions a candidate asks at the end can help show us whether their engagement with the school has been superficial or meaningful.”

4. REHEARSE UNDER REALISTIC CONDITIONS

Mock interviews are the most effective preparation you can do. They help you test your pacing, catch blind spots you can’t hear yourself (filler words, jargon, answers that lose their thread), and experience the pressure of being put on the spot in a safe setting, so you’re calmer on the day. If possible, practice with a coach who knows the school’s format and can simulate it closely. Fortuna’s MBA interview prep sessions are run by former admissions decision-makers and alumni interviewers who know these formats from the inside.

Practice your presence as well as your content. Confidence grows with preparation, and a few habits help it show: upright posture, steady eye contact (on video, look at the camera from time to time), and a warm smile. Taking a brief pause before you answer is perfectly fine and reads as thoughtfulness.

Plan the logistics too. For a virtual interview, test your technology, choose a neutral background and set your camera at eye level. For an in-person meeting, wear something that makes you feel confident and professional (see our tips on what to wear for your MBA interview), and bring a printed copy of your resume. Either way, arrive or log in a few minutes early so you have time to settle.

5. CLOSE WELL AND SAY THANK YOU

Alumni interviewers are volunteers, so a genuine thank-you at the end of the conversation matters. Follow up with a brief, professional email within a day or so, or a handwritten note if the setting suits it. Mention something specific from your discussion, which shows you were listening and leaves a warm final impression as they sit down to write their report.

FINAL THOUGHTS: CONFIDENCE AND CLARITY WIN

The alumni interview is your opportunity to show who you are once the resume is set aside. Admissions committees want to know that you will thrive in their program and that you will contribute to the community their alumni care so much about. The person interviewing you is part of that community, which makes their impression of you especially valuable to the committee.

Approach the conversation with clarity about your story, confidence in your preparation and genuine curiosity about the school and the person in front of you. Do that, and you’ll leave your interviewer with an easy report to write: I’d genuinely want this person as a classmate.

---

Melissa Jones is a Senior Expert Coach at Fortuna Admissions and a former Assistant Director of MBA Admissions at INSEAD. For more free advice from Fortuna Admissions in partnership with Poets&Quants, check out these videos and articles. For a candid assessment of your chances of admission success at a top MBA program, sign up now for a free consultation.

© Copyright 2026 Poets&Quants. All rights reserved. This article may not be republished, rewritten or otherwise distributed without written permission. To reprint or license this article or any content from Poets&Quants, please submit your request HERE.